This is that rare movie that feels as if it
couldnt have been acted or written any
better. It takes many liberties in its
depiction of author J.M. Barries (Johnny
Depp) intentions and inspirations for his
legendary Peter Pan, but only a
true ogre would allow this to be
bothersome. The relationship at this
films center, Barries paternal friendship
with four boys after the loss of their father,
is beautifully depicted. And while many a
film wouldve chosen to allow Barrie and
the childrens mother, Sylvia Llewelyn
Davies (Kate Winslet), to embark on a
torrid affair, director Marc Forster
(Monsters Ball) and screenwriter
David Magee wisely keep the relationship
platonic. As Barrie, Depp is the polar
opposite of the immensely enjoyable
camp he put forth as Captain Jack
Sparrow in Pirates of the
Caribbean. His performance is one of
subtlety and sweetness. Depp renders
Barrie both virtuous and heroic while
barely bringing his voice (effectively
disguised with a Scottish accent) above
conversational tones.